NEAR UNANIMOUS
After trimming roughly the most extreme 10% of ratings on each side, the spread is no more than 1 point. The main body of votes keeps the game in almost the same place.
COMMUNITY TIER LIST
Every saved tier list, averaged into one collective diagnosis of gaming taste.
TIER LISTS COUNTED—
GAMES RANKED—
MIN. RATINGS10
HOW IT WORKS
The top tier of each list is worth 5 points, the bottom 0; everything between is scaled automatically. Tier names do not matter — only their order. A game appears here after 10 different saved tier lists.
Calculating collective opinion…
NOT ENOUGH EVIDENCE YET
A game needs to appear in at least ten saved tier lists before it can enter this ranking.
STABLE OPINION
The robust spread is 1.01 to 2.10 points. The disagreement is visible, but most voters still place the game in roughly the same part of the tier list.
OPINIONS SPLIT
The robust spread is above 2.10 points, but there is no full split into two camps. The average is already smoothing over a real disagreement around the game.
CIVIL WAR
The robust spread is above 3 points, with at least 15% of votes in both the high and low ends of the scale. At that point people are no longer arguing about placement — they are arguing whether the game is good at all.
